Skip to content

Manchester City defender Vincent Kompany has been blasted as 'rash' by Sky Sports pundit Gary Neville

It is difficult to see where Manchester City defender Vincent Kompany’s next good game is coming from, according to Sky Sports pundit Gary Neville.

The City skipper was in the spotlight after just 11 minutes of his side’s 2-1 defeat at Liverpool as Philippe Coutinho snatched the ball off him and raced away towards Joe Hart’s goal before finding Jordan Henderson, who curled the ball into the top corner.

Kompany was heavily criticised for his performance during City’s Champions League defeat to Barcelona and Neville dubbed the Belgium international 'Mr Rash’ after watching an unconvincing display at Anfield.

A dejected Vincent Kompany
Image: A dejected Vincent Kompany

“Vincent Kompany has turned into Mr Rash,” the former Manchester United full-back said

“I don’t know what’s happened to him. He needs to settle his game down. Kompany loses out on a 50-50 with Coutinho.

“He’s going through a difficult moment, Vincent Kompany. It’s hard to know where his next good game is coming from.

“We’ve all been through those periods. He’s usually someone who is so dominant and a leader for this team, every time the ball goes near him he’s struggling.”

Manuel Pellegrini admitted he had spoken to Kompany following City's 2-1 defeat to the La Liga side and the stats back up Neville's assertion that the centre-back has gone off the boil.

Manchester City goalkeeper Joe Hart (centre) shouts at his defence after conceding the second goal of the match during the  Champions League Group E match
Image: Manchester City goalkeeper Joe Hart (centre) shouts at his defence after conceding the second goal of the match during the Champions League Group E match

City's win rate with Kompany at the heart of their defence is just under 58 per cent and the 28-year-old has won just 53 per centof his duels this term.

Fellow Sky Sports expert Jamie Carragher also criticised his display against Brendan Rodgers' side, but also pointed to failings in midfield.

The former England defender, reflecting on Kompany's failed attempt to dispossess Coutinho, said: “Vincent Kompany, one of the best centre-backs in world football, that is a shocking challenge. It might sound crude but he’s either got to win the ball or foul Coutinho.

“Brendan Rodgers would have been delighted when he saw Manchester City playing 4-4-2. We always talk about the problems City have in the centre of midfield.

“Because those two central midfielders are not aware of what’s going on around them, the knock-on effect is that Kompany feels he has to step in when it’s not his job. Mangala is then left on his own."

But another former Liverpool defender, Phil Thompson, jumped to the defence of Kompany, claiming his confidence has been affected by Pellegrini’s tendencies to chop and change his back four.

“I think the biggest problem is actually who’s playing alongside him,” Thompson told Sky Sports.

“They’ve changed their back four so much this season and, for me, it’s knocking Kompany’s confidence.

“Zabaleta has not been as good this year, while Clichy and Kolarov are being alternated between games.

“And the centre-half alongside him, whether it be Mangala or Demichelis, are changing far too often too. There’s no consistency around him and it’s causing him to underperform.”

Around Sky